TGen-led Study Discovers Genetic Cause of a Rare Type of Ovarian Cancer

TGen-led study discovers genetic cause of a rare type of ovarian cancer. Scientific breakthrough could lead to new cancer treatments; study inspired by the memory of Taryn Ritchey, a 22-year-old patient who lost her battle to the disease.

The cause of a rare type of ovarian cancer that most often strikes girls and young women has been uncovered by an international research team led by the Translational Genomics Research Institute (TGen), according to a study published online recently by the renowned scientific journal, Nature Genetics. [1] In a scientific rarity, two additional studies with similar results were also published online on the same day in Nature Genetics, producing immediate validation and reflecting a scientific consensus that usually takes months or even years to accomplish. [2-3]

By applying its groundbreaking work in genomics, TGen led a study that included: Scottsdale Healthcare, Mayo Clinic, Johns Hopkins University, St. Joseph’s Hospital and Medical Center; Evergreen Hematology and Oncology, Children’s Hospital of Alabama, the Autonomous University of Barcelona, British Columbia Cancer Agency, University of British Columbia, and the University Health Network-Toronto.

The findings revealed a “genetic superhighway” mutation in a gene found in the overwhelming majority of patients with small cell carcinoma of the ovary, hypercalcemic type, also known as “SCCOHT.” This rare type of ovarian cancer is usually not diagnosed until it is in its advanced stages. It does not respond to standard chemotherapy, and 65 percent of patients with the disease die within 2 years. SCCOHT can affect girls as young as 14 months, and women as old as 58 years – with a mean age of only 24 years old. In this study, the youngest patient was 9 years old.

The three separate groups of international researchers reported strikingly similar scientific findings related to SCCOHT, as provided below.

  • Identification of germline (i.e., inherited) and somatic (lifetime acquired) inactivating mutations in the SWI/SNF chromatin-remodeling gene SMARCA4 in 75% (9/12) of SCCOHT cases, in addition to SMARCA4 protein loss in 82% (14/17) of the SCCOHT tumors. Notably, only 0.4% (2/485) of the other primary ovarian tumors tested possessed similar genomic characteristics. [Ref. 1]
  • Identification of recurrent inactivating mutations in the SMARCA4 gene in 12 of 12 SCCOHT tumor samples. [Ref. 2]
  • Indentification of germline inactivating mutations in familial cases of SCCOHT. Through additional analysis of non-familial tumors, the researchers determined that nearly 100% of tumors carry SMARCA4 mutations, and 38 of 40 lack protein expression.[Ref. 3]

Collectively, these findings implicate inactivating mutations in the SMARCA4 gene as a major cause of SCCOHT, and may lead researchers to improvements in genetic counseling, as well as the development of new targeted therapy treatment approaches.

Dr. Jeffrey Trent, President and Research Director of TGen, is the study's senior author.

Dr. Jeffrey Trent, President and Research Director of TGen, is the study’s senior author.

“This is a thoroughly remarkable study. Many genetic anomalies can be like a one-lane road to cancer; difficult to negotiate. But these findings indicate a genetic superhighway that leads right to this highly aggressive disease,” said Dr. Jeffrey Trent, President and Research Director of TGen, and the study’s senior author. “The correlation between mutations in SMARCA4 and the development of SCCOHT is simply unmistakable.”

Dr. Trent added that while the breakthrough is for a relatively rare cancer, discovering the origins of this type of ovarian cancer could have implications for more common diseases.

Much of the work in this study was inspired by the memory of Taryn Ritchey, a 22-year-old TGen patient who in 2007 lost her battle with ovarian cancer, the 5th leading cause of cancer death among American women.

“Taryn would be incredibly excited about this amazing new study, and she would be glad and thankful that other young women like her might now be helped because of TGen’s ongoing research,” said Taryn’s mother Judy Jost of Cave Creek, Arizona. “My daughter never gave up, and neither has TGen.”

The SMARCA4 gene – previously associated with lung, brain and pancreatic cancer – was the only recurrently mutated gene in the study’s samples. The implications of this discovery, therefore, may be widespread.

“The findings in this study represent a landmark in the field. The work identifies SMARCA4 mutations as the culprit, and most future research on this disease will be based on this remarkable discovery,” said Dr. Bert Vogelstein, Director of the Ludwig Center at Johns Hopkins University, Investigator at the Howard Hughes Medical Institute, and pioneer in the field of cancer genomics. He did not participate in the study but is familiar with its findings.

“The past decade of research has taught us that cancer is a vastly complex disease. Profound patient-to-patient variability has made treatment and diagnosis for many tumor types at times very difficult. In this case, however, we have found a single genetic event driving SCCOHT in nearly every patient,” said Dr. William Hendricks, a TGen Staff Scientist and another author of the study.

“We have shown that loss of SMARCA4 protein expression is extremely specific to SCCOHT and can facilitate the diagnosis of SCCOHT,” said Dr. Anthony N. Karnezis, a fellow at the British Columbia Cancer Agency located in Vancouver, Canada, and one of the study’s authors.

Pilar Ramos, a TGen Research Associate, is the study's lead author.

Pilar Ramos, a TGen Research Associate, is the study’s lead author. “By definitively identifying the relationship between SMARCA4 and SCCOHT, we have high confidence that we have set the stage for clinical trials that could provide patients with immediate benefit.”

“By definitively identifying the relationship between SMARCA4 and SCCOHT, we have high confidence that we have set the stage for clinical trials that could provide patients with immediate benefit.”

“We set out to uncover any small sliver of hope for women afflicted with this rare cancer. What we found instead are the nearly universal underpinnings of SCCOHT,” said Pilar Ramos, a TGen Research Associate, and the study’s lead author. “By definitively identifying the relationship between SMARCA4 and SCCOHT, we have high confidence that we have set the stage for clinical trials that could provide patients with immediate benefit.”

The TGen-led study was supported by grants from: the Marsha Rivkin Center for Ovarian Cancer Research, the Anne Rita Monahan Foundation, the Ovarian Cancer Alliance of Arizona, the Small Cell Ovarian Cancer Foundation, and philanthropic support to the TGen Foundation. Further support was provided by the Terry Fox Research Initiative’s New Frontiers Program in Cancer, and the Canadian Institutes of Health Research.

For more information about TGen’s research into small cell carcinoma of the ovary (SCCO), or to participate in a future study, visit: www.tgen.org/scco.

About TGen

Translational Genomics Research Institute (TGen) is a Phoenix, Arizona-based non-profit organization dedicated to conducting cutting-edge genomic research to accelerate breakthroughs in healthcare. TGen is focused on helping patients with cancer, neurological disorders and diabetes, through cutting edge translational research (the process of rapidly moving research towards patient benefit). TGen physicians and scientists work to unravel the genetic components of both common and rare complex diseases in adults and children. Working with collaborators in the scientific and medical communities literally worldwide, TGen makes a substantial contribution to help our patients through efficiency and effectiveness of the translational process. For more information, visit: www.tgen.org.

References:

1./ Ramos P, et al.  Small cell carcinoma of the ovary, hypercalcemic type, displays frequent inactivating germline and somatic mutations in SMARCA4. Nature Genetics (published online 23 March 2014) doi:10.1038/ng.2928.

2./ Jelinic P, et al. Recurrent SMARCA4 mutations in small cell carcinoma of the ovaryNature Genetics (published online 23 March 2014) doi:10.1038/ng.2922.

3./ Witkowski L, et al.  Germline and somatic SMARCA4 mutations characterize small cell carcinoma of the ovary, hypercalcemic type.  Nature Genetics (published online 23 March 2014) doi:10.1038/ng.2931

Additional Information:

 

30-Day Mortality Associated With Primary Cytoreductive Surgery In Elderly Advanced Ovarian Cancer Patients Much Higher Than Previously Reported

Researchers affiliated with the University of Washington have determined that the 30-day mortality rate associated with primary cytoreductive surgery in elderly patients with advanced ovarian cancer is much higher than previously reported.

Researchers affiliated with the University of Washington have determined that the 30-day mortality rate associated with primary cytoreductive surgery in elderly patients with advanced ovarian cancer is much higher than previously reported. There research is based upon the analysis of statistics obtained from the National Cancer Institue (NCI) Surveillance, Epidemiology, and End Results (SEER) database (collectively, the NCI SEER database).

Melissa M. Thrall, M.D., Lead Study Author; Fellow, Department of Obstetrics & Gynecology, University of Washington School of Medicine

The lead author of the study is Melissa M. Thrall, M.D., a Fellow in the Department of Obstetrics & Gynecology, University of Washington School of Medicine.

The researchers used the NCI SEER database to identify a cohort of 5,475 women aged 65 and older, who had primary debulking surgery for stage III or IV epithelial ovarian cancer which was diagnosed from 1995 through 2005. Women were stratified by acuity (i.e., average severity of illness) of hospital admission. Multivariable analysis was performed to identify patient-related and treatment-related variables associated with 30-day mortality.

The overall 30-day mortality rate was 8.2% for the 5,475 women who had surgery for advanced ovarian cancer. Women admitted on an elective basis experienced a 30-day mortality rate of 5.6% (251/4,517), while those patients admitted on an emergency basis experienced a 30-day mortality of 20.1% (168/835).  The researcher determined that 84.4% of patients were admitted on an elective basis, 15.6% of patients were admitted on an emergency basis, and 2.2% of patients had an unknown admission status.

Emergency admission was associated with older age (median of 76.9 vs. 75.1 for elective admission), higher comorbidity scores, and stage IV disease (41.9% vs. 32.9%). Women admitted on an emergency basis had surgery performed more frequently in low-volume hospitals, by low-volume surgeons, and by surgeons other than gynecologic oncologists (p value <0.001). Emergency admission was also associated with significantly less use of neoadjuvant chemotherapy (2.99% vs. 13.39%, p <0.001).

Advancing age, increasing disease stage, and increasing comorbidity score were all associated with an increase in 30-day mortality (p <.05) among elective admissions. The mortality risk was not influenced significantly by race, income, marital status and other demographic and clinical factors.

A group of women at high risk who were admitted on an elective basis included those aged 75 or older with stage IV disease, and women aged 75 or older with stage III disease and a comorbidity score of 1 or more. The high risk group experienced a 30-day mortality rate of 12.7% (95% confidence interval: 10.7%–14.9%), and accounted for 25.7% of the study population and approximately 50% of the deaths.

Low-risk patients were defined by age 65 to 74, stage III or IV disease, and a morbidity score of less than or equal to one. The low-risk patients accounted for 48.7% of the study population and experienced a 30-day mortality rate of 3.64%. The remaining intermediate patients experienced a mortality rate of 6.05%.

Based upon their analyses, the researcher concluded that age, cancer stage, and comorbidity scores may be helpful to stratify patients admitted on an elective basis by predicted postoperative mortality risk. If validated in a prospective cohort study, these factors may help identify women who may benefit from alternative treatment strategies, such as neoadjuvant chemotherapy.

The study was supported by the Marsha Rivkin Center for Ovarian Cancer Research and by the National Cancer Institute.

Sources:

Related WORD of HOPE Ovarian Cancer Podcast

Symptom Screening + CA-125 Blood Test = Better Detection of Early Stage Ovarian Cancer

” …Research has found that when used alone, a simple four-question symptom-screening questionnaire and the CA125 ovarian-cancer blood test each detect about 60 percent of women with early-stage ovarian cancer and 80 percent of those with late-stage disease. This study found that when used together, the questionnaire and blood test may boost early-detection rates to more than 80 percent and late-stage detection rates to more than 95 percent. …”

“Women’s reports of persistent, recent-onset symptoms linked to ovarian cancer – abdominal or pelvic pain, difficulty eating or feeling full quickly and abdominal bloating – when combined with the CA125 blood test may improve the early detection of ovarian cancer by 20 percent, according to new findings by researchers at Fred Hutchinson Cancer Research Center published online today in CANCER.

Research has found that when used alone, a simple four-question symptom-screening questionnaire and the CA125 ovarian-cancer blood test each detect about 60 percent of women with early-stage ovarian cancer and 80 percent of those with late-stage disease. This study found that when used together, the questionnaire and blood test may boost early-detection rates to more than 80 percent and late-stage detection rates to more than 95 percent.

‘Of course, it is the increase in the detection of early-stage disease that is the most exciting,’ said lead author M. Robyn Andersen, Ph.D., an associate member of the Public Health Sciences Division at the Hutchinson Center. Cure rates for those diagnosed when the disease is confined to the ovary are approximately 70 percent to 90 percent. However, more than 70 percent of women with ovarian cancer are diagnosed with advanced-stage disease, when the survival rate is only 20 percent to 30 percent.

‘This research suggests that if a woman has one or more symptoms that are new for her, having begun within the past year, and if the symptoms happen nearly daily or at least 12 times a month, that may well be a signal to go in and discuss those symptoms with her doctor,’ Andersen said. ‘It’s probably not going to be ovarian cancer, just as most breast lumps are not breast cancer, but it’s still a sign that it might be worth checking with her doctor to see if a CA125 blood test and transvaginal ultrasound may be appropriate.’

Assessing the symptoms included in the symptom-screening index may already be done by some doctors based on a consensus statement issued last year by the National Institutes of Health. The researchers hope their symptom index will help doctors know which among their patients who complain of symptoms such as abdominal swelling and pelvic pain might have cancer.

The symptom-screening index, developed in 2006 by paper co-author Barbara A. Goff, M.D., professor and director of Gynecologic Oncology at the University of Washington School of Medicine, is not used proactively in clinical general practice, but Andersen and colleagues are conducting a pilot study to assess the value of using it as a screening tool among normal-risk women as part of their routine medical-history assessment.

For the just-published study, the researchers administered the symptom questionnaire to 75 women about to undergo surgery for pelvic masses who were later diagnosed with ovarian cancer (the case group), and 254 healthy women at high risk for ovarian cancer due to a family history of the disease (the control, or comparison, group). The cases were recruited through Pacific Gynecology Specialists at Swedish Medical Center in Seattle, and the controls were recruited through the Ovarian Cancer Early Detection Study, a joint project of the Hutchinson Center and the Marsha Rivkin Center for Ovarian Cancer Research.

The National Institutes of Health/National Cancer Institute, the Marsha Rivkin Center for Ovarian Cancer Research and the Canary Foundation supported this research.”

[Quoted Source: Symptom screening plus a simple blood test equals a 20 percent jump in early detection of ovarian cancer, Fred Hutchinson Cancer Research Center News Release, June 23, 2008.]